Saturday, January 14, 2012

The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes - movie 1970


Summary: A woman appears at Mr. Holmes's door, having no idea of her name nor even of her reasons of coming. Apparently, she'd been the victim of attempted murder and nearly drowned... Mr. Holmes decides to take the case. 

This movie adresses directly some of Holmes most controversial habits, such as his addiction to cocaine and his sexuality. It also questions Dr Watson's scriptures by constantly doubting their precision and the fact that Dr Watson had romanticised Holmes' adventures and maybe left his unsuccessful cases aside.

Holmes is depicted just as in the Canon: witty, mischievious, full of life and humour... but still elegant and very british (also not that keen of conventions) in behaviour. Watson is not that endearing unfortunately, being used more as a comic relief than as a valid companion to such a clever man, even though he does speak his mind and is not just an admirative tool of Holmes'. Mycroft's fans will be pleased to notice his presence in the movie and the importance of his part. Of course the overall acting is quite different from our day's, quite theatrical I'll say.

Personal opinion: This is one of the best interpretations of the Canon I've seen so far. I'm quite sure Sherlock's fans would enjoy it immensely. I might even venture to say that the writters of BBC Sherlock have probably inspired themselves from some parts of this movie -or maybe good interpretations of the Canon can't help but look alike, just as siblings somehow look like each others.

Thursday, January 12, 2012

Shaun of the Dead - 2004 movie

Shaun of the Dead: 2004 British zombie romantic comedy.
Directed by Edgar Wright,
Starring Simon Pegg and Nick Frost. You might recognise Martin Freeman as Declan as a bonus.

 

Summary:
Shaun's life is a total disaster: he spends his life playing video games with his friend Ed, forgetting about his mother's birthday (he hates her new husband) and his girlfriend's anniversary (she dumps him). On top of that, he's disrespected at work and exasperating his roomate.
However, a zombie apocalypse arrises just in time to give him... well, even more trouble. He thus decides to go fetch his mum and ex-girlfriend to bring them somewhere safe, namely, his favourite pub. Of course other people tag along -such stepdads, friends and more zombies.

Comment:
I'm not fond of gore and horror movies, but this was fun as hell. I enjoyed it as much as Braindead -probably more as it was a tat less "hollywoodian" and the plot more subtle, or more British, I don't know. I'll recommend it to anyone who likes a good parody and who's not afraid of seing people being teared appart.

Sherlock Holmes - 2009 movie


I wasn't fond of this movie at first. Neither at second, actually. But it's not bad, it's not bad at all; I'm just a bit of a purist. 

Sherlock - Russian series: The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson


The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson (Приключения Шерлока Холмса и доктора Ватсона) was made by Soviet television and directed by Igor Maslennikov. It starred Vasily Livanov as Sherlock Holmes and Vitaly Solomin as Dr. Watson in lenght features cut into multiple episodes.

More details: here.

Episode list:
1979 - Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson
1980 - The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson.
1981 - The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson: The Hound of the Baskervilles.
1983 - The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson: The Treasures of Agra.
1986 - The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson: The Twentieth Century Approaches.

Global opinion:
If you like the Canon, you'll probably enjoy this adaptation. It's quite classic but nicely handled, and the actors have a kind of warmth to them. This Sherlock is a bit more into action and disguises than others, and Watson is not an admiring idiot of his but a real companion (in a non sexual kind of way, you perv'). You might notice the lack of budget in city sceneries, but that'll give you a glimpse to some russian city; why whine then?

Bonus: russian is a wonderful language, real music to the ears! As for the actual soundtrack, it was writen by Vladimir Dashkevich (thanks for buddy2blogger for having me notice). 

Case of Evil - Sherlock Movie, 2002


I watched it because I thought the hero looked cute. What did I expect? A good Sherlock Holmes? L.O.L.

Let's be clear: I'm not against infractions to the Canon, if they're pertinent and well handled. Those clearly weren't. 
- Sherlock is young: ok, all right, why not? He had to be young someday. 
- He's brilliant, but no-one gets him: fine. A tat emo in this movie, but he's making his debuts as a detective, so maybe.
- He's a ladykiller: err, what? Sherlock, interested in women? Adler aside, he despises them and bodily urges. Did you go for lady killer? That would have been at least probable.
- He got into the investigation business to avenge family: NO. Sherlock Holmes is NOT an avenging family kind of person. In fact, aside from Mycroft, does he even care about family? About people, yes, maybe, a bit. Sometimes. But about persons he's chained to by society? Bah.
- He's against drugs. Sherlock. is. against. drugs.
- He's got morals. I am now officially crying. 
-About Watson: he's a doctor. An (ex)military man? Well, if you believe he's still in shape to run, maybe. But Watson was often disregarded into Sherlock films, so that's not even a surprise. 
-Moriarty... is not clever, just a vile drug dealer. I'm not even proceeding with this list anymore. 

This is NOT a Sherlock movie. An action movie, perhaps, if you count as action a bit of firing at the end. This is the very classic story of the teenage-boy who seeks recognition from his father (who's dead, but conveniently reimplaced by Watson as a father figure), from society (by murdering bad men and banging women), from his loved-one (even though I'm not sure why he loves her, they've only met for one day and she's said like five uninteresting words to him -oops, wait, my mistake, she's pretty).

To conclude: Sherlock is a poor traumatised as a child genius, he sleeps with girls, he fights bad men, people eventually like him and come to think that he is a heroe.  

Bad reason to watch the Canon be raped: Sherlock's pretty. (I did say it was a bad reason).
Good reason to watch this movie: as bad as it is, it suspect it might have taken a role into the recent turn of events concerning the modern interpretation of the Canon. A younger Sherlock, a more action-like movie about his adventures: isn't it what the 2009 Sherlock Holmes and the Sherlock BBC series are pointing at now? Maybe this was the first attempt to renew our interpretation of the Canon. The failed first attempt.

The last word: I won't even bother writing it myself:
"[L]et's just accept the idea that Sherlock Holmes needs to be sexed up and made relevant for a twenty-first century audience. Do writer/producer Piers Ashworth and director Graham Theakston manage to make an entertaining movie out of that? No. In their hands, Sherlock becomes a generic hero tortured by the past and Moriarty becomes a thug without any sort of air of mystery about him." Jay Seaver of eFilmCritic.